KJ (owlmoose) wrote,

  • Mood:

architecture of the city

There's an interesting article on SFGate today about city planning in San Francisco, a review of an essay examining SF's resistance to ground-breaking architectural design. The essay accuses the city's planners and residents of being over-attached to the Victorian style and allowing urban design to stagnate as a result. The author of the article concedes this, admits to being guilty of the same attitudes, and wonders if it will be bad for the city in the long run.

I don't have many complaints about living in SF, but this issue is definitely one of them. There's a powerful, vocal contingent that seems to want the city to be a museum to 1973, and architecture is a big part of that. While I agree that some people (ahem*Willie Brown*ahem) are a little too devoted to progress for the sake of progress, I think an automatic "change is bad" reaction is just as problematic. In my opinion, not enough change is just as bad for a city as too much radical change. A vibrant city is one that attracts new residents, new businesses, new kinds of people, and I worry that SF is not that kind of place right now. It's a very suburban attitude, and so short-sighted. Everyone complains about the lack of affordable housing, then the same people fight high-rise housing projects because they "don't fit with the image of San Francisco." I don't know what the answer is. Currently, the city is searching for a new city planning chief; maybe they'll find someone to help us break out of this Victorian-shaped box.
Tags: city/architecture

  • April update; May goals

    Days written: 21/30 Words written: 8,706 Words of fic written: 5,175 Stories worked on: Four (one all editing) Stories posted: One new, one…

  • End of an Era: Goodbye LJ

    This is my final crosspost to LiveJournal. I think you all know why. The LJ community was a wonderful space for me for a long time, but it hasn't…

  • So, NOW are we all quitting LiveJournal?

    Being required to accept a Terms of Service written in a language that most of us can't read is majorly dicey. Although from what little I know, it…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded